JOHN CARTER of MARS COMMENTS:
​

  The Burroughs books ...  are clearly labors of love. Every aspect, from typography and careful editing to design and production are outstanding. The bindings are handsome, the dust jackets and illustrations are spectacular. The paper is clearly chosen for durability. These are books that any admirer of Edgar Rice Burroughs and his works will be proud to own and to preserve for generations to come.                       --Richard A. Lupoff, Author

The books are simply wonderful!  ..........   Peter M.

Marvelous. That one word says it all. The illustrations, the dedication, the new introduction, the extras, the craftsmanship...... Marvelous.   William H. 

 I love the books. .... You produce books the way they should be produced.   Steve S.

I received my books today.  I've never seen anything like this JCoM set.  A few words come to mind like stupendous, magnificent, awesome, unbelievable, etc.  You get the drift.   Frank P.

"A Home Run" - ​I know your email box is overflowing w/ praise, but I’ve just got to jump in and add mine too.  JOHN CARTER is gorgeous.  Actually unbelievable.  I can’t ever recall seeing such complexity delivered in a book. And for the price point, incredible.  Every aspect of the books ooze the highest level of care and quality.  Art, type, paper, binding, slipcases; all marvelous.  And the Remarques are very impressive.  Well done, Jim!  I’m most proud to be adding these two books to my collection.  Jack J.

​Just finished opening up your package with the two John Carter of Mars books.  Wow!!  These overshadow even the other books that you have done!  They are beautiful!  The most impressive tribute to a story that I have seen! 
The illustrations couldn't be more fantastic!  I was trying to describe these books to a friend of mine.  Difficult to do.  Illustrations from the pulp version, the Big Little Book (cover & interior), the Canaveral Press & Bantam Books editions - not to mention Bob and Doug's fabulous covers!  Everybody was in on this one!  And the text bonuses were equally terrific - especially Richard Lupoff's old and new introductions - and the bibliography.  Amazing!  Great stuff!  Beautiful leather slipcases.  And the Limited Extras were grand - the medallion and various letters/postcards from Canaveral to Henry Hardy Heins, Caz and Vern Coriell!  A literal trip down fan memory lane. Like I said, a magnificent tribute to this book!  Thanks so much for producing such beautiful products! Sign me up for whatever is next!  ............... Terry M.

I just received my John Carter of Mars Limited Edition Set and I want to congratulate you on another superb job. These editions are magnificent. The attention to detail and the quality of each volume Edgar Rice Burroughs himself would have been proud of. The artwork by different contributors from the past is a collectors dream come true. I look forward to future editions of these great works of literature honoring the legacy of their creator and the artists that stirred the imagination of the characters and the worlds they inhabit.   Mark S.

Your two incredible books arrived on Friday, but I did not cut open the shrink-wrap until today.  You know, I have been feeling a strong urge to not open the books, but rather to  insert them into a 3-D picture frame and treat them as art works.  Seriously.  I felt that way with the previous volumes, but these books are getting more and more amazing with each new version.   ​Bob Z.

​In Depth Review:
​
"John Carter of Mars" -- A Dream Come True By John Martin
EDGARDEMAIN: Celebrating the literary legerdemain of Edgar Rice Burroughs  

Some people are dreamers, and some are dreamer-doers.   Many fans of Edgar Rice Burroughs have dreamed sometimes of ERB books that would contain multiple illustrations -- from the old pulps and from later editions of the books, as well as stunning new art.   Jim Gerlach has also dreamed of such things, but Jim is also a doer, and he's done it -- again!  

Two new editions of "John Carter of Mars" have just been published and contain the type of art mentioned above, plus much, much more.   The two editions are being offered in to two sets: the 52 lettered sets (A-ZZ)," were sold out in advance, and the numbered sets (#1-348).   As of press time you can still order available numbered sets on the website - www.erbbooks.com  

When I use the word "sets," I mean that Jim Gerlach is selling these books in sets of two.  Each set contains the two books, with different bindings, titling and publishers; unique limitation pages, title pages, enclosures and  end matter and alternative dust jacket art and layout.  One of the books is an ERB Inc. edition, done with blue binding and similar to that on the books Edgar Rice Burroughs, Inc., published in the latter part of his life. These books have a dust jacket with art by Douglas Klauba, showing John Carter taking on the "Skeleton Men of Jupiter."  

The other book is a Grosset & Dunlap edition, done with traditional red binding, featuring a dust jacket with art by Bob Eggleton showing John Carter about to have an encounter with a white ape.   The publication of the ERB Inc.  and "Grosset  & Dunlap” editions are authorized by agreement with each company, and  the G&D edition of "John Carter of Mars" has the distinction of being the 50th ERB title to be published by that company, so that in itself makes it a milestone volume.  

The dust jacket illustrations of both books are used as frontispieces in the other books:  
--The Eggleton art for the jacket of the G&D edition is used as a three-page foldout for the frontispiece of the Burroughs edition.  
--The cover and spine section of the Klauba art for the jacket of the Burroughs edition is used for the frontispiece of the G&D edition.  

Both editions are dedicated to Richard A. Lupoff, the editor at Canaveral Books in the early 60s who headed the efforts to bring many of ERB's books back into print in hardbound editions, and to bring some stories out in hardback versions for the very first time. That was when the first hardback edition of the John Carter adventure, "Skeleton Men of Jupiter," appeared in hardback. It was published on July 24, 1964, in the volume titled "John Carter of Mars" along with "John Carter and the Giant of Mars."

​In that era, many believed that "Giant of Mars" had also been written by ERB. However, it was later established that it had actually been written by ERB's talented son, John Coleman Burroughs, specifically for a Big Little Book. An article by Robert R. Barrett, detailing the detective work that established the son's authorship, is included as an extra in the new volumes published by Gerlach.   

Both books feature:  
--The color frontispieces mentioned above  
--A three-page color foldout scene in the middle of the book  
--Five full-color two-page foldout plates  
--Eleven one-page color plates  
--Three formerly black and white illustrations colored with tint blocks (two blue, one pink)  
--Two double-page black and white illustrations  
--Thirteen one-page black and white illustrations  
--Seventy-two of the 207 smaller black and white illustrations made by John Coleman Burroughs for the Big Little Book "John Carter" edition.  
"Phil Normand colorized eight images in the book.. and did an amazing job," said Gerlach. "It included two J. Allen St. John images and six Reed Crandall illustrations."  
The written contents of each book include:  
--"John Carter and the Giant of Mars," credited to John Coleman Burroughs  
--"Skeleton Men of Jupiter," written by Edgar Rice Burroughs  
--Foreword by Kevin J Anderson, "Dreaming of Barsoom"  
--Introduction by Richard A. Lupoff, including the introduction of the 1964 Canaveral edition  
 --(G&D edition only)  List of ERB G&D reprints at the end of the book as well as a listing of all the various ERB G&D titles and printings on the verso of the dust jacket.  
--ERB's notebook pages for "Skeleton Men of Jupiter"  
--"John Carter of Mars: The Completely True and Factual Story Behind the Story," by Robert R. Barrett   --"A Good Place to Quit," by Richard A. Lupoff (originally, Chapter 16 of Lupoff's "Barsoom: ERB and the Martian Vision."  
--"A Bibliography of John Carter of Mars" by Robert B. Zeuschner   Other features of both books;  
--A signature page signed by Eggleton, Klauba, Anderson and Lupoff. (Note: In order to obtain these four signatures, a box with the 800 sets of those particular pages had to be "Fed-Exed" from the printer in Nashville to Lupoff in California, who signed and sent to Klauba in Chicago, who signed and sent to Eggleton in Rhode Island, who signed and sent to Anderson in Colorado, and then back to the bindery in Texas.)  
--Bookmark. The die-cut bookmark is double-sided and printed on 160# card stock, with the art reversed on one side to match the die-cut, but different text blocks on each side to promote both the G&D and Burroughs editions When the books were shipped, the G&D side of the bookmark was placed face-up in the G&D edition, and likewise with the ERB Inc. side up in the Burroughs editions.  
--(ERB Inc Edition only) A replica copy of a letter that Lupoff, as editor at Canaveral, mailed to fanzine publishers Camille A. Cazedessus Jr. and Vernell Coriell, and to Henry Hardy Heins, author of "A Golden Anniversary Bibliography of Edgar Rice Burroughs" in reference to the coming publication of John Carter of Mars...was included in each ERB Inc. edition.  
--(G&D Edition only)A replica copy of a 1963 or 1967 postcard sent by Lupoff explaining the incorrect title used on the first Canaveral edition of "John Carter of Mars" was included in each G&D edition (the binding on the cover of the first printing had the words "John Carter and the Giant of Mars" rather than just "John Carter of Mars.")  
--A Medallion/coin with the engraved set numbering on the front instead of being engraved on the edge like the first coin to be issued with a Gerlach book, the one that came as a bonus with "Savage Pellucidar. Thomas Grindberg drew the John Carter image that is on the heads side of the coin. One coin was issued per set.    
--Binding: The G&D binding features the vintage black stamped titles on the cover and spine of the book The stamping on the blue ERB Inc edition is red/orange as were the originals. Zavier Cabarga designed two different styles of titling for the ERB Inc. and G&D book cover and spine stamp and the title page lettering.  
--Endpapers feature a color map of Barsoom. Gerlach designed the map and gave his sketches to an artist in Italy, who digitally rendered them. It was reviewed several times before the final version was ready.  
--Slipcase for each book. The slipcase for the Numbered sets is of Cialux cloth and the one for the Lettered sets is of deluxe bonded leather. 

* * * * The Lettered Editon had some extras that were not available in the Numbered Edition.These include:  
-While all G&D editions included a replica postcard explaining the original title misprint (see above), the Lettered Editions actually have replicas of two postcards, written differently and mailed to two different people.  
--An original sketch opposite the signature page, drawn by the artists when they received the pages to sign. In addition to those remarqued sketches, the artists also signed those pages in addition to the regular signature page.  Eggleton added original sketches to the G&D editions and Klauba added original sketches to the Burroughs editions.

*  * * * *   Jim Gerlach started his "ERB Books" publishing several years ago when he came into possession of most of the original printing plates for the first edition of "Back to the Stone Age," plus a more limited number of plates for two other ERB books, "Cave Girl" and "The  Chessmen of Mars."   Gerlach used the original "Back to the Stone Age" plates to reprint the book in two stunning new editions, an ERB Inc.-style "Publisher's Edition" and a G&D editon. Thanks to the fan acceptance and success of that, he has followed up with similar twin editions of the last two books in ERB's inner-world series, "Land of Terror" and "Savage Pellucidar."  

Gerlach is pleased that "Interest is growing slowly with each title. We're trying to improve every successive title and add bonus features." Besides the idea for the coins and bookmarks, he  added the Canaveral postcards and letter discussed earlier in this article. He noted that "John Carter of Mars" has a total of 21 color plates (including the frontispiece), and 88 black and white illustrations on text stock, "by far the most we've ever done. “In fact," he added, "this is the most profusely illustrated ERB book ever.”   Gerlach was pleased that, though the "John Carter" editions were the most costly set to produce thus far, "yet we managed to not raise the price of either the numbered or lettered sets."  

The print runs for each edition:  
--"Back to the Stone Age," the Publisher's Edition, with original bookplate, in clamshell case, was made in 300 sets, 279 of them numbered and 21 lettered. Each lettered volume included a chapter title printing plate and original sketch by Tom Grindberg There was also a G&D Edition published and made available with a choice of two different dust jackets. There were 300 of those. So there were 600 BSA books in total.  
--"Land of Terror" was 200 numbered and 52 lettered sets, a total of 504 books.  
-"Savage Pellucidar" included 248 numbered plus 52 lettered sets, for a total of 548 books.  
--"John Carter of Mars" was 348 numbered and 52 lettered sets, for a total of 800 books.   (There have been 52 lettered sets because the amount corresponds to two run-throughs of the alphabet, editions distinguished by the letters A to Z and AA to ZZ.)  

Most of Gerlach's books sell with advance orders, but there are usually some extra sets of the numbered editions available from his website.    To be assured of obtaining future volumes published by Gerlach, please go to his ERB Books website and sign up on the popup box for email updates. He also has other ERB books for sale in the "Store" section of the website. See: https://www.erbbooks.com/  

And a future volume is definitely in the works. Gerlach has announced the next book he plans to publish will be "A Princess of Mars -- The Manuscript Edition."
​
EDGARDEMAIN: Celebrating the literary legerdemain of Edgar Rice Burroughs